Neurofeedback refers to the process of feeding a sensory representation of brain activity back to users in real time to improve a particular brain function, e.g., their focus and/or attention on a particular task. This study addressed the notable lack of research on methods used to visualize EEG data and their effects on the immersive quality of VR. We began by developing an algorithm to infer a quantitative indication of focus in the form of a focus score. A pre-study involving twenty participants demonstrated the efficacy of the algorithm in differentiating between focused and relaxed mental states. The focus score was then employed in an exploratory study exploring the impact of various neurofeedback visualization schemes in terms of one’s engagement in the VR experience and ability to focus. The results provide important insights into the design of neurofeedback visualization schemes aimed at enhancing the focus of participants in VR.